Feeds and Alerts

Answers to ‘Surge protection for Powerline Ethernet products?’

Works for me... 

Anonymous Coward • Friday 14th September 2007 09:41 GMT

I have three Solwise 85Mbps adapters. One is plugged straight into the wall, one is plugged into an multi-way extension lead and another is plugged into a multi-way with built in surge protection. They all work fine (obviously, or I would have tried something else!!).

I suspect the manufacturer's concern is that they can't guarantee the devices will work with ALL surge protection or multi-way plugs, so they choose to advise you not to use them to avoid a slew of returns.

YMMV!

Just avoid those with noise filters. 

Myself • Friday 14th September 2007 18:11 GMT

The Tripp-Lite Isobar series, for instance, feature inductive chokes and capacitors that clamp down on noise traveling the powerline, which is precisely what your adapter relies on.

The cheapest of plugstrips should work fine. Those with MOVs for surge protection should work fine. Those with MOVs, inductors, and filter caps will definitely eat the signal.

Official feedback: it works, but it's not recommended 

Tony Smith, Editor, Reg Hardware • Monday 17th September 2007 11:36 GMT
staff

I put Quddus' question to Devolo, one of the suppliers of powerline Ethernet kit. Here's what Peter Huddleston, who looks after the company's products here in the UK, had to say:

"We discourage surge protection units as these incur heavy noise onto the powerline which in turn affects the signal. Yes, sometimes they can work fine, and users experience no problems - but still we discourage.

"The actual devolo adapters have an integrated fuse so if there is a power surge, the adapters are independently secured."

And with that, and the other responses, that's this question answered.

The period for answering this question has finished

Ask a Question

Troubled by technology? Want to know which is the best product to buy? Need a hand getting the most out of your gadgets? Email us to submit your queries to the combined brainpower of your fellow Register Hardware readers.

Q & A

  

Editors’ Blog

Which top-of-the-line graphics card should I buy?

I play Crysis and Half-Life 2-based games on a PC connected to a 50in Pioneer Kuro plasma, but my old GPU is starting to show it's age. What should I replace it with?

Ricky Cann

Click here to add your answer

  

Airbus A380-800: an airborne treat for gadget fans

I'm writing this sitting in a Singapore Airlines double-decker Airbus A380 bound for the carrier's home city. We're at 35,320ft and I'm up in tech heaven.

Continued...