By andrew mulcockPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 16:48 GMT
Having seen many translations of manuals in the past few years, I can believe that it's just a lazy translation, involving cut and paste from previous lap top manuals.
My favourite was the Japanese translation into German into English which read on the lines of:
flick switch 'a' and the red light comes on, flick switch 'a' again, and dark comes on.
By David GosnellPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:05 GMT
I also like the way the manual says it's OK to wash the display panel with water, without giving any definite guidance as to how much or whether the device should be powered down at the time. Now that could be a useful "cure" for the dead pixels Asus apparently refuse to warrant against since the Eee is officially not a laptop.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:16 GMT
The third, and most logical conclusion would be that a technical writer / translator used a canned text (one possibly required by the Asus lawyers in every user's guide), and then did a search and replace some time later.
A simple copy-paste error. But a drunken Reg "journalists" makes this into a big discovery. As a hint: Your readers aren't as stupid as you think they are.
By Chris CPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:20 GMT
Or perhaps a third option, the manual wasn't actually written by engineers and they just all their standard gumpth which they used for every laptop. Oh yeah, but don't call it a laptop as asus don't, Hmmmm legtop??
By Adam WilliamsonPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:26 GMT
...the manual (especially the boring, standard warning sections) was created largely by cut and pasting bits together from the manuals for other products, and no-one caught that including this one didn't make a lot of sense on a system with no hard disk.
I'm fairly sure most of the pre-release discussion of the eee - even months back when it was initially going to be released - talked about solid state storage.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:52 GMT
This is standard warning text, taken from a content management system / translation database and updated by a Technical Author (not necessarily an Engineer).
To save translation costs, it is common practice to re-use as much existing content as possible. This excerpt looks exactly like the kind of text that could be common to the user manuals of all Asus notebooks.
Of-course the updated text should be subject to a formal review before release, but it may be possible that this one slipped through the net.
By Stuart GrayPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:18 GMT
Back in the day, there were many more British exam boards than the "big three" that now exist in England. One, the Midland Examining Group (or MEG) was responsible for many Physics papers. This board amalgamated to be become Oxford, Cambridge and RSA (or OCR), and all the old syllabi were duly converted to the new name. So we Physics teachers had to teach (if we were to follow the syllabus to the letter) that electricity was counted not in Megawatts, but Ocrawatts....
Stuart
Further proof the Eee was supposed to have a hard drive #
By M1ndPosted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:54 GMT
Anyone who has tried using an Eee on their lap will instantly know something is wrong - the balance is completely off. The base of the laptop is too light and lifts up, making 'lap top' use well-nigh impossible. Add a hard drive and hey presto the sucker would keep itself firmly planted where latops are meant to go.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Wednesday 5th December 2007 01:05 GMT
"I have nothing to add - just wanted to post from my lovely little Eee..."
For Christ's sake whaterver you do, Mmm, remember that to prepare the Eee PC for transport, you should turn it off. The solid-state disk's head retracts when the power is turned off to prevent scratching of the solid-state disk drive surface during transport.
By Adrian EsdailePosted Wednesday 5th December 2007 01:33 GMT
Nice computer, shame they have to market it like beer. My partner in IT gets quite peeved that computer marketing droids still think the average IT user is a 15-year-old male with a fixiation on stroke mags.
The 'EEE picture' is not the way to market to women, thats for sure. Nor does The Reg help by peddling it.
By Stuart Van OnselenPosted Wednesday 5th December 2007 07:45 GMT
Does your partner really expect marketroids to entertain anything as dangerous as (gasp!) "a new thought"?
(Or any thought, for that manner.)
They've all seen War Games (or Hackers if they're too young) and that's it - All computer users are 15yo wankers -err - "Solo Sex Aficionados". Plus, all the other marketroids advertise IT with mammaries, and who are they to buck the trend?
Now slap a campaign together ASAP, so we can get back to sniffing the Bolivian Marching Powder out of the navels of the models.
OK, I apologise for offending any real marketroids who might be reading this - my comment is obviously a grossly distorted and sweeping generalisation. It's just that my objectivity goes out the window when sex is used to sell *anything*, but especially in the IT arena.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Wednesday 5th December 2007 09:18 GMT
"Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance"
Robert Pirsig’s excellent novel "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" is in part about alienation of people from modern technology, and had a very funny account of how instruction manuals are written, from a character (based on the writer himself), who used to be a technical writer. As he tells it, the company needs to write a manual for a new product. They go down to the production line and ask the manager there to relapse someone to help them with writing it. The manager gives them the biggest goof-off on the shop floor, as during the time they are absent, the rest of them might actually get some work done. Goof-off knows little about the product, and the manual is a mess. Public gets even more alienated from technology…
By Anonymous CowardPosted Wednesday 5th December 2007 11:03 GMT
she is a hottie alright - and the ad worked on me! I got one and am really happy with it (SNES emu mainly as the small screen is perfect for making the graphics look wonderful again).
Defo change the Paris angle to where is the eee-beachbird angle?!!
Comments on: Asus dropped hard disk from Eee PC at eleventh hour
urgh lay off the find/replace #
By Karl Lattimer Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 16:35 GMT
that photo... #
By andy rock Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 16:41 GMT
I'm beginning to think... #
By Terry Ellis Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 16:45 GMT
just lazy #
By andrew mulcock Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 16:48 GMT
Cleaning the screen #
By David Gosnell Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:05 GMT
More likely #
By Lisa Parratt Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:14 GMT
Stupid #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:16 GMT
3rd option #
By Chris C Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:20 GMT
Third... #
By Adam Williamson Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:26 GMT
engineers??? #
By Chris Wilson Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:41 GMT
Third possible explanation: #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 17:52 GMT
That photo... #
By Russ Tarbox Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 18:17 GMT
Getting like Private Eye & the Andrew Neil pic (with Pamella Bordes) #
By H2Nick Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 18:19 GMT
I depend on me #
By Ashley Pomeroy Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 20:15 GMT
@ Russ T #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 20:18 GMT
On the Other Other Hand... #
By Snert Lee Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:00 GMT
Mmm #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:15 GMT
Not the only find & replace cock up #
By Stuart Gray Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:18 GMT
Further proof the Eee was supposed to have a hard drive #
By M1nd Posted Tuesday 4th December 2007 22:54 GMT
The bird ! #
By Uwe Dippel Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 00:38 GMT
@mmm #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 01:05 GMT
Please grow up. #
By Adrian Esdaile Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 01:33 GMT
@Adrian Esdaile #
By Stuart Van Onselen Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 07:45 GMT
Asus Marketing Dept will love you #
By Timbo Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 08:56 GMT
"Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 09:18 GMT
Not just the camera.... #
By Tharglet Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 09:48 GMT
I concurr #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 5th December 2007 11:03 GMT