Reg Hardware

Comments on: BT Vision targets Xbox gamers for growth

Current kit not HD capable? 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 15:05 GMT

The current Philips kit can output a 720p or 1080i signal over HDMI - indeed that's how I have it set up at home and the user interface is rendered in HD along with an upscaled freeview picture.

I've no idea whether it will support over-the-air HD (if that ever happens), but given that BT often pushes firmware updates to the box (as it's always connected to the internet through the homehub) it doesn't seem impossible.

Accurate! 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 15:31 GMT

Coat

"The service is slated..."

Got that bit right, anyways...!

More importantly 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 15:37 GMT

Stop

Is the second gen box going to be free for me; an early adopter?

Re: Current kit not HD capable? 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 15:37 GMT

(Written by Reg staff.)

Hi,

It's an input, not an output issue.

The current boxes won't be capable of decoding HD Freeview signals, which is likely to be broadcast as a tightly compressed MP4 signal, and broadcast over DVB-T2, which together will provide the necessary extra bandwidth for HD.

MP4 requires more hardware power, not software updates. The Philips doesn't have a DVB-T2 tuner either - I believe the standard is still a draft.

If BT were to provide HD at the current mpeg-2 compression, on demand over the IPTV stream, that might be a different matter...except that it would require much faster downstream speeds than ADSL can currently offer.

- Chris

cr@p software 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 16:04 GMT

If BT were looking for growth, then maybe they should get some decent programmers and fix the crap software that doesnt allow more than one vision box on a broadband line and fix the program guide thats so slow its painful to use!

PS It will be in the landfill long before true HD/mp4 appears....2012??

Maybe I'm being thick... 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 17:07 GMT

...but what's the benefit to the customer? If I still have to have a separate PVR in order to use Vision, what benefit am I getting from this? If the 360 had a Freeview tuner and the box was effectively replacing the Vision STB/PVR then I could see the benefit. Maybe BT should have done their deal with Sony as the PS3 WILL have a Freeview tuner soon.

Pointless 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 17:56 GMT

I already have on-demand (well downloadable) movies and Freeview on my 360 - Windows Media Center. Plus it has the best EPG i've ever seen and I can record tell / pause live TV.

Cost = £50 for a TV Tuner added to my Vista Ultimate machine.

If you already have XP MCE or Vista Home Premium / Ultimate, just slap on a TV tuner and get it that way.

Screw BT. Plus what is the point of having a 360 when your tied to BT for the ISP. As you probably couldn't play games on their crap infastructure anyway.

Soooooo.... 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 18:24 GMT

.....pay for more BT garbage, like we don't pay them enough, or download HD telly from torrents and wifi-stream it to my PS3 in the living room with TVersity for free.

Nah, not impressed.

Only 100,000 users im not surprised 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 19:01 GMT

tried to order it today mainly cause i want the series record and the power plug networking and was told that my 2400 line is not good enough (You only need a 2000 line).I suspect that the 100,000 are those you can pratically touch the exchange from the front gardens.

Thanks but no thanks... 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 19:16 GMT

Gates Halo

I'll continue recording TV off freeview and sky and streaming it onto my Xbox 360. No further subscriptions required. Besides, not even wild horses could drag me to use BT Broadband dis-services.

BT vision - works fine for me... 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 19:33 GMT

Thumb Up

I think if you pop over to digital spy you will find a lot of users are more than happy with what BT Vision has to offer.Admittedly it was a bit flakey at the start but after a few fw upgrades it now works a treat..

100,000 punters to date? 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 20:14 GMT

Alert

Strip out all the BT employees who had it foisted on them whether they wanted it or not (in lieu of the shares that were taken away) and how many are left?

In fairness, it's not a bad product for the telco's first toe in the water, and has improved immeasurably since launch.

It also has one added bonus - if you're a BT Total Broadband punter who also takes Vision, they route your support calls for both to Customer Service in Newcastle, rather than their infamously piss-poor Boys In Bangalore.

What about the caps? 

Posted Monday 7th January 2008 20:28 GMT

Stop

Does it have any impact on their fair usage policy?

@ Chris Williams 

Posted Tuesday 8th January 2008 09:07 GMT

Boffin

Actually the current Philips box is capable of MPEG4 decoding, however you are correct of course that it lacks a DVB-T2 tuner (since such a thing doesn't even exist yet as far as I know as the standard hasn't even been finalised). If the BBC had decided to go ahead with its proposed 4-hour overnight BBC HD service on freeview as MPEG4 over DVB-T then the current box should have been able to view it just fine.

@Caps 

Posted Tuesday 8th January 2008 10:54 GMT

Thumb Up

Vision traffic does not use your download quota so it wont matter. The real reason i suspect the 360 support is coming in is because its pretty simple to implement. Mainly because Vision uses Microsoft's IPTV stuff :)

It will also be a good deal cheaper than the marketplace...

Re: @ Chris Williams 

Posted Tuesday 8th January 2008 12:32 GMT

(Written by Reg staff.)

Thanks for the correction, ahead of its time in that respect I guess. Cheers,

- Chris

BT vision on xbox ... BT what ? 

Posted Wednesday 9th January 2008 22:42 GMT

"BT vision to comes to Xbox" - and lo there was a collective shrug of the nations shoulders as they continued not to care about BT vision ....

Possible to have HD before Freeview? 

Posted Friday 11th January 2008 09:55 GMT

Alert

BT are missing a trick here. According to MS bumpf, Mediaroom is perfectly capable of handling a HD stream over IPTV. Why not trumpet BBC HD and 4HD ahead of Freeview? This would make Vision an option for early adopters who A) Don't want to give Sky any money and B) Don't want a dish when Freesat comes out.