Comments on ‘LG laptop goes up in flames’

just when its really needed! 

Coat

Wheres the video?

Scaremongering 

Just another one of this BBC / ITN style news reporting rubbish.

Just how many Lithium Ion / Polymer gadgets have actually exploded or caught fire in the last decade? Id wager less than 100 in maybe 10 years, if anywhere near that sum.

Now how many Lithium Ion / Polymer batteries have actually been produced over the last 10 years? Go on, how many hundred Billions are we talking about?

.

In the same way as we're continually led down the path that we'll all die from the supposed salmonella outbreak some time back, or to some extent the supposed bird flu epidemic due our way, so we take this crap from Journalists.

If we're so caught up on individual cases - I couldn't easily count the amount of LiON batteries I have in my home, and over the abuse I've given some of them over the years, not a one has caused my house to burn down.

Not good journalism guys.

.

Overall am I correct in saying theres a higher chance of being hit by the proverbial lightening strike?

Serves 'im right - photos too hot to handle? 

Coat

Photos too hot to handle, eh? I'll get me coat...

@Stu - Scaremongering 

Flame

One in a billion chance? Not if they're all made the same way - then there's a much greater chance that whatever design defect caused an unplanned disassociation of one battery could cause the same of many others.

Just hope that you're not too near that you get burned, but near enough to put out the flames.

This laptop will self-destruct in seven seconds... 

Coat

This "unnamed" reporter is obviously some sort of spy. Either that, or he got his laptop mixed up with that of a good old fashioned secret agent.

He must've slept through the warning that all self-destructing spy devices are required to give.

My coat and bag, please. No need for hat or gloves today, as it's quite nice out.

@ Stu 

"Overall am I correct in saying theres a higher chance of being hit by the proverbial lightening strike?"

Yes. And that there's a better chance that GW Bush and Osama will sit down and settle their "differences" over a nice cuppa down t'local. Assuming you believe they have any real differences.

@Ludwig 

Stop

True, that is a possibility, and so should be investigated scientifically for real dangers as opposed to scaremongering into thinking all LiON batteries are fundamentally flawed.

For all we know this nameless journo purposefully abused it to try and prove some kind of laptop battery danger conspiracy, but could have ended up deliberately abusing it for weeks or months before it exploded (above that of normal wear and tear) - so isnt it interesting he/she is keeping shtum about who they are and the exact details?

Of course manufacturing techniques (amongst lots of other factors) will increase or decrease the 'susceptibility' to explosion/fire, but have we not already established the event is a rarity in relation to the amount of batteries actually produced? And so individual factors must be quite small.

Q & A

 

Editors’ Blog

Which is the best Linux for laptops?

I have been starting to venture into the Linux/Unix world, currently using the Ubuntu 8.04 on my ThinkPad X60. But is there a better distro for mobiles?

Thomas Roche

Click here to add your answer

 

Lovefilm 1, BitTorrent/iTunes/retail 0

I've given up buying DVDs, though I haven't stopped watching them. Quite the reverse - I'm watching more movies and TV series than ever before. Before you suggest it, I'm not downloading anything either...

Continued...