Comments on ‘Steve Jobs' Macworld Expo spiel spied on web?’

Ifs its real 

Thumb Down

Its disappointing, I want applications for my AppleTV god dammit.

Well... 

Thumb Down

There were fake lists like this last year too, I think the Mac Pro reference makes me think that it's fake.

Mr Jobs does not do "Rough Drafts" 

The steely one starts with a presentation of such high polish that mere mortals could not approach it and then works upwards.

Thus this is a forgery.

Bugger 

Linux

I was hopeing something more like:

"Greetings lady and gentlemen. Welcome to MacWorld 2008! Now, we've realised that we sppare to have made a community that is one of the most annoying on earth. Therefore, could you please reach under your seats, pull out your brand new iKnife, and commit ritual Hari Kari."

Well, I can hope. (Can you tell I've had a bad- no, wose than usual day with the mac fans at work?)

Just More Pre-Macworld PR Pimping 

Jobs Horns

It's the ONLY thing that Apple Does well (their hardware / softrware is for $hit) and that's pimping the Media with crap to hype their Vaporous meeting of Kool Aid Drinkers at the Fruits - Nuts -n-Flakes Bowl that is MWSF.

The ANSWER IS .... who F__king Cares?

Of course it's fake 

All you have to do is look at this section:

iPhone

- Sales beyond our wildest dreams

- Much more than the 1% market share we asked for in January

Total horseshit. Everyone knows that it's been selling like crap, there's no way they're at 10 million devices. Unless they're counting devices "sold" to Carphone Warehouse and the like, who are totally unable to move them to end-users.

Not likely, is it? 

Thumb Down

I'd assume that a fifth version of the draft wouldn't have rather obvious problems like pushing the same point twice, like this one does with the app pricing för the Phone and Touch...

Real Mac Pro specs 

Thumb Down

Apple released the Mac Pro refresh last week so the real specs for the base model are:

Two 2.8GHz Quad-Core Intel Xeon “Harpertown” processors

2GB memory (800MHz DDR2 fully-buffered DIMM ECC)

ATI Radeon HD 2600 XT graphics with 256MB memory

320GB Serial ATA 3Gb/s 7200-rpm hard drive1

16x double-layer SuperDrive

$2,799 is the price.

The only thing right in the 'keynote' is the Superdrive speed.

Why would Jobs... 

Jobs Horns

...put that information on any web server, local or internet facing? Surely he'd have it on his computer and his little speech helpers would have it on theirs too; but there is no need for it to be anywhere else yet. If this is the real thing, then he wanted it to be 'leaked' - perhaps he thought it would be a publicity spinner for the expo. Who knows.

Personally, I think it's made up by that site to attract attention, which it seems to have done quite well.

Ben

Mac Pro specs are wrong 

Thumb Down

The Mac Pro specs are those for the previous update. Neither 7300GT nor Quadro 4500 are available as an option. I'm surprised about the Mac Mini stuff, but the 320Gb drive option can't be real. Very suspicious, but interesting otherwise. I doubt that a consumer keynote would spend so much time on the iPhone SDK.

It's not real 

They only just refreshed Mac Pro last week; why would they do it again this week?

Lame 

Stop

Youtube on iTunes? Very Lame.

BBC iPlayer content on AppleTV, on the other hand...

A good effort but definitely fake. 

Jobs Halo

For starters the Mac Pro has already been put out there, the MacBook is very unlikely to get a refresh before the MacBook Pro, the magsafe adaptors are even more unlikely to have aluminium ends as this is likely to be a safety issue.

Good spoof but not good enough.

I'm betting it's fake 

Stop

If this were real, it would probably have the sales figures, etc. in it rather than just say "Sales Figures". Besides, the real thing's probably kept locked up almost as secure as the gold in Ft. Knox.

Depends what you were looking for 

Thumb Up

I'd actually be pretty happy with that list; mostly because my only Apple product is an iPod Touch, which appears to be a major fucus, and I adore last.fm. Ability to submit plays, and receive radio streams would finally start to make use of the device's capacity.

Getting The Orb on the device would be a pretty awesome too, and I imagine someone will design an app (although I understand this is possible already with a hacked software).

Sorry - not buying it 

Thumb Down

This has all the earmarks of a hoax... and a rather poorly researched one at that. Most telling is that all existing models of MacBook and MacBook Pro are shipping "within 24 hours" from Apple and BTO configurations are shipping in the normal 1-3 days. If Apple replaces products in their product line, you almost always see them lean out the channel in advance.

A change to the MagSafe power adapter is highly unlikely unless there's a major design change or a safety issue. Changing the cable end to aluminum just doesn't make sense.

As others have pointed out, the Mac Pro was just refreshed and the "specs" here are incorrect. This is obvious rubbish.

Faaaaaake! 

Thumb Down

Dual core as base for Mac Pro? They don't sell dual cores anymore!

@Scott 

Joke

of course the real keynote locked up securely, it's saved on a mac with the firewall disabled.

oh, hang on...

I know for a fact this is fake 

Happy

The real keynote outline is at

http://www.crazyapplerumors.com/?p=1016

Really like we're supposed to believe this one there isn't even one mention of wireless pudding.

Very Funny 

Go

Fake steve strikes yet again !

Very poor 

Paris Hilton

And one more thing ... PH joining Apple board.

No, really, the biggest fake alert was trying too hard to get it 'taken down' ... it's way too well written to stay on wikipedia servers for long.

Frankly obvious 

A blog claiming WackyPedia as source ? It has got to be true !

Yeah, right. And I'm King Tut.

Fake 

Happy

Nowadays; "...and boom!" would be part of the script outline itself :-)

Who the hell is taking this seriously? 

The content is irrelevant. Here is the post to Wikipedia - http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Macworld_Conference_%26_Expo&diff=183215796&oldid=64332664. It's an anonymous post to a talk page with no attempt to claim authenticity. It's total rubbish, obviously completely made up. If it hadn't attracted a bunch of comments it would probably have been immediately removed, instead it took a couple of days (though it's still in the history - if it had been real, it would probably have been deleted).

Void Inside's reprinting it is a great example of the journalistic standards of the blogosphere. Shame that El Reg seems to think it has to follow suit.

Look out for next week's story: "Apparently, someone's friend Johnny is dumb and smells of pee. Source: Shiteforbrains.blogspot.com who cleverly spotted an edit to Talk:Sonic The Hedgehog on Wikipedia."

Macs for all 

Jobs Halo

It's fake as there's no mention of the 'Macs for all' scheme where if you go to an 11 hour seminar on why you should pay through your nose for Apple merchendise you get a free Mac.

Very poor 

Thumb Down

See how tired the writer of this hoax had gotten only 1/4 of the way in:

" Sales are getting better and better every day "

Scott I noticed that too. Is that a Steve Jobs keynote line? No, it sounds more like somebody on a 12-step recovery program.

"- Hardware sales figures/market share

- Leopard released October; doing spectacularly

- Sales figures/market share"

Needless repetition. Then the hoaxter gives up completely -

"Patents abound"

Pathetic.

If internet hoaxes are this lame, I should start spreading stock rumours...

Q & A

 

Editors’ Blog

How can I free 'hidden' hard drive capacity?

I've seen drives that offer 120GB and others that offer 160GB, yet both have one platter and two read/write heads. So, are they identical?

Cameron Sollie

Click here to add your answer

 

Acer Aspire One: the new sub-laptop to beat?

Early reviews of Acer's £220 Aspire One were none too complementary about its build quality, but have spent a brief time with a unit that's not a pre-production model, we'd say Eee PC creator Asus has a real challenge on its hands.

Continued...