Comments on ‘Scientists sue Intel in Core 2 Duo clash’

"Warf is asking the court to declare that Intel's Core 2 Duo product infringe its patents" 

Joke

Poor Intel. I don't think I'd like to argue with a Klingon.

Standard Silicon valley Practice 

So what's the big deal? I'm on my 4th startup. The use of whatever solution works regardless of patent infringement, and letting the infringed party figure it out and come after you, is the norm in Silicon Valley.

Amateurs 

Thumb Down

filed in the wrong court for this type of thing west Texas is where you want, oh well what do they need money for anyway.

Warf is asking the court to declare that Intel's Core 2 Duo product infringe its patents 

Coat

Make it so!

These are boffins? 

This patent sounds like "we used historic data as a guide to future behaviour". REAL scientists call this using experimental results (including null ones) to form a hypothesis and it is so far from being novel that you ought to get your bollocks roasted for even *trying* to patent the idea.

Devil, er, Intel Inside 

Thumb Down

I'm slow I guess.

Just figured out how Intel works.

1. See competitor with better chip (Opteron)

2. Steal tech from others to crush competitor.

3. Pay a tiny % of total intake to resolve #2

4. Hold huge percentage of market, with little or no real penalty (when looking at the overall big picture).

I'm not anti-capitalism, but it does appear that the game is played in a fashion that, to "win" is to become a monopoly.

Heghlu'meH QaQ jajvam 

Flame

P'Tok! Hab SoSlI' Quch!

@Amateurs 

Boffin

Actually you're thing on the Federal Court of The Eastern District of Texas.

Easy mistake, merely 1000 klicks off.

@Devil, er, Intel Inside by Anonymous Coward. 

Happy

Opteron (Barcelona) the better chip? so where is it?

http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=7339

stealing techs from competitor. hmmm, the Core 2 Duo has long been using 128-bit internal data paths and Barcelona (as well as phenom) just adopted it. L3 cache? this is old intel server technology. and many more here:

http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/article/480

@Amateurs 

Alien

Ummm you are sort of right but WARF is from the University of Wisconsin. (This sort of hints WHERE they are at!) As they are a part of the STATE OF WISCONSIN, they are subject to the State of Wisconsin laws. Taking this to court in Texas would be like the UK taking someone to a court in France - won't happen.

title 

Alert

Just buy them off, Intel. A year on, and Core2 is still demolishing the desktop market, and the core-derrived Xeons aren't doing too bad either. Don't let anything rain on your (For once, well-deserved) parade.

besides, if you have to stop selling Core2's, you may be forced into desktop Itanic.

....scary thought, isn't it?

Q & A

 

Editors’ Blog

Which is the best Linux for laptops?

I have been starting to venture into the Linux/Unix world, currently using the Ubuntu 8.04 on my ThinkPad X60. But is there a better distro for mobiles?

Thomas Roche

Click here to add your answer

 

Lovefilm 1, BitTorrent/iTunes/retail 0

I've given up buying DVDs, though I haven't stopped watching them. Quite the reverse - I'm watching more movies and TV series than ever before. Before you suggest it, I'm not downloading anything either...

Continued...