By Chad H.Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 16:53 GMT
perhaps you should replace the dictionary with "fact checking for dummies".
2gb data? Where did you pull that from, there's no mention of that on the o2 website, in fact the terms and conditions specificly unlimited, not unlimited*, not fair usage applies, just unlimited. Full stop. In fact the no hidden limits on their plans is something o2 pride themselves in (as long as the usage is caused by human interaction, not by a script or automatic dialer or similar, its allowed.
You can be pretty sure that you'd hear about it if the 'unlimited' was really 2GB. I've not heard of anyone being disconnected or charged for going over any limit - in the UK, US or the rest of Europe...
By Nicholas MoorePosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:20 GMT
Whilst it does seem you're right about the data limit - there doesn't seem to be one - it does surprise me to find this: "You may not use your ... iPhone to allow the continuous streaming of any audio / video content"
So iPhones can't use (or should I say, aren't supposed to use) YouTube? That's a surprise.
In their defense, O2 is I think one of the few operators that allow truly 'unlimited' broadband (provided you're not using your phone as a modem through a laptop etc).
However, for other operators/ISPs etc, the whole "unlimited" (Fair Usage applies) fiasco really makes me mad, too. I don't understand how they're allowed to hide away the fact it is nowhere near unlimited in the T&C's? - Does anyone know why Ofcom etc allow it?
Your O2 tariff for iPhone allows you unlimited use of O2 UK's EDGE/GPRS networks and The Cloud's UK Wireless LAN network, for personal internet use, email and Visual Voicemail (VVM) on your iPhone only. All usage must be for your private, personal and non-commercial purposes. You may not use your SIM Card in any other device, or use your SIM Card or iPhone to allow the continuous streaming of any audio/video content, enable Voice over Internet (VoIP) P2P or file sharing or use them in such a way that adversely impacts the service to other customers of O2 or The Cloud. If O2 reasonably suspect you are not acting in accordance with this policy O2 reserves the right to impose further charges or disconnect your tariff at any time, having attempted to contact you first.
Note that it says no CONTINUOUS video/audio streaming, not none whatsoever. They basically mean you can't use your iPhone as a TV or radio that is just constantly playing streaming audio/video. As far as I'm concerned that clause does not restrict the likes of YouTube.
By Rik HemsleyPosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 18:32 GMT
Ofcom allow companies to get away with such scams as unlimited* because Ofcom are pathetic and because it's in the government's interest to keep Ofcom toothless.
By Matt KempPosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 19:07 GMT
It's unlimited access to the EDGE network and The Cloud's wifi spots.
If I remember correctly, the contract also specifies you can't use it for IM or streaming media - You can't legally stream iTunes music store or Youtube over it, and the BBC iPlayer website specifically mentions that 2.5G isn't fast enough for streaming their programs. They're meant for use over wifi - If I remember correctly, americans even have access to technology now which allows them to order from starbucks over their iPhone to save them having to actually communicate with people (ironic, given the medium).
Interesting idea about a 3G iphone in June - I'd be interested to see if apple/O2 will be offering trade-ins on older models, though I doubt it.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 19:37 GMT
only '3' appears to understand the needs of the mobile data user.
they have no problems taking VoIP data...and if your unfortunate to think that skype is voip then at least your skype data is a freebie! (doesnt count to overall useage)
i've said it once, i'll say it again, iPhone is only serious when its got 3G ability. iPhone is only serious when it lets you do some of the stuff on non-Wifi links. and its only a serious purchase on those expensive monthly contracts if the phone comes free!
until then, N95. and maybe N96 later this year if iPhone2.0 turns out to be a minor cosmetic crappy upgrade on same stupid limitations
By Chris GibsonPosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 21:05 GMT
Stating "i've said it once, i'll say it again" doesn't really count for much when you don't put your name against your posts.
I agree with you about the 3G issues, the iPhone will clearly be a better handset with a 3G connection. However, I'm amazed at how many people on this website -- surely primarily aimed at IT professionals? -- object to the cost of an iPhone. Are you really saying that the iPhone isn't a "serious purchase" unless it's free?
For what it's worth, I've "said it once and I'll say it again": if you're on a tight budget, the iPhone probably isn't the right handset for you. In fact, I've just checked the O2 website, and they'll charge you £99 for an N95 on an 18 month £35 p/m contract anyway. So why recommend the N95 over the iPhone? Does that extra £70 really make all the difference?
By Bruce RobinsonPosted Tuesday 15th April 2008 23:50 GMT
This price drop is surely a shelf clearing exercise and I'm waiting for iPhone II.
I moved to a short term contract with Orange just for this situation. The iphone 1 was never going to make a real long term tool. Apple were just using it to test the water.
Now they should know what the punter want and I’ll be ready to shelve Orange and their appalling service as soon as the iphone 2 is released, subject to improved functionality, a reasonable price and decent contract conditions. Maybe on the same terms as Oz or China (Ha, Ha).
If these improvements don’t happen, then its a Samsung or SE for me and many others I’m sure. (..and Apple will have lost the chance to clean up in the phone war; the competition will not give them another chance to get it right. They will be shafted and rightly so.)
By NiallPosted Wednesday 16th April 2008 08:12 GMT
O2 Ireland don't mention unlimited because it is in fact limited to 1GB with a 2c per MB charge in excess. I'd love to see the figures for iPhones in Ireland, the deals compared to everywhere else are a total rip off.
By Dominic BradburyPosted Wednesday 16th April 2008 08:21 GMT
As someone who sold their original iPhone unlocked and for a profit on ebay, the £100 price-cut suddenly makes a re-buy an interesting proposition. At that price I can justify it as a 'Friday' phone and use my W890i (Fab) the rest of the time.
Let's face it, Apple/CW/O2 will probably slash the price of the 3G iPhone in 6 months so I may just bide my time until then. Then I'll unlock my re-bought iPhone and shove it on ebay.
I think there'll always be a market for good condition unlocked iPhones regardless of whether they are 3G or not.
At the end of the day it is a fashion phone. It looks great, will impress people in the pub but is not of a great deal of use to people that need a higher-end phone for practical reasons. It will take 2 or 3 more generations of iphone to come up with something useful and competitive.
And what are these higher end practical reasons? #
By RIchPosted Wednesday 16th April 2008 11:35 GMT
Makes the tea? Drives you home after impressing your friends in the pub?
It doesn't do blackberry sync, but only blackberries do.
And FW2.0 supposedly does MSX active sync.
I use gmail on it which is fine.
The phone sound quality is good
The battery life is acceptable
The Ipod is, well, an Ipod
Videos are pretty good.
The web browser is better than any other mobiles I've played with.
The camera is sh1te and unless you jailbreak them they are pretty poor in terms of applications. If you do they are pretty good.
And if I need to impress down the pub its not my phone I get out...
the unlimited data access period probably is per month, yes. but seeing as you pay them 35quid each month, then you get unlimited data each month too
at least, in the 5 months i've had my iphone with o2, i've used it for tons of data access and i keep checking and every bill there's never any charge for data useage
You must have agreed to be spammed to get the £100 #
By RichardPosted Wednesday 23rd April 2008 19:00 GMT
I got this from Carphone Warehouse;
"In regards to this offer being offered relating to the Iphone there are
the following terms and conditions.
- You must have purchased your Iphone at the higher price on or after
the 17th March
- *** You must have provided permission for Direct Marketing and other
information to be sent to you*** at the time when you purchased your
Iphone." (My emphasis)
As I see it then, if you said no to being spammed when you activated, you're not getting your pennies.
Comments on: Official: O2 and Carphone Warehouse to slash 8GB iPhone price
UNLIMITED ACCESS #
By Ash Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 16:32 GMT
3G iPhone? #
By jon Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 16:52 GMT
@ ash #
By Chad H. Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 16:53 GMT
@Ash #
By Repo Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:06 GMT
2GB? #
By Ed Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:13 GMT
@Chad #
By Nicholas Moore Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:20 GMT
"Unlimited*" #
By Tag Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:43 GMT
O2 wi-fi policy - no streaming video or VoIP #
By nacnud Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 17:47 GMT
no CONTINUOUS streaming #
By Steve Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 18:04 GMT
Why Ofcom allow it #
By Rik Hemsley Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 18:32 GMT
iPhone usage #
By Matt Kemp Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 19:07 GMT
unlimited? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 19:37 GMT
@ Anonymous Coward #
By Chris Gibson Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 21:05 GMT
Buy 1 now or buy 2 later? #
By Bruce Robinson Posted Tuesday 15th April 2008 23:50 GMT
Hmmm... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 04:31 GMT
Whats a title????? #
By James O'Brien Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 05:50 GMT
2GB you'd be lucky #
By Niall Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 08:12 GMT
iMoan #
By Dominic Bradbury Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 08:21 GMT
Apple confirms no price cut from them #
By Andy Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 08:58 GMT
Jailbreak time #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 09:21 GMT
Value in a way #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 09:34 GMT
Still too expensive. #
By Luke Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 10:57 GMT
And what are these higher end practical reasons? #
By RIch Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 11:35 GMT
Extra £100 - get the phone for £69 #
By Mark Barton Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 12:10 GMT
re: Rich #
By Tony Chandler Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 12:19 GMT
BB Connect #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 14:32 GMT
re: Whats a title????? #
By jai Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 16:13 GMT
You must have agreed to be spammed to get the £100 #
By Richard Posted Wednesday 23rd April 2008 19:00 GMT