Reg Hardware

Comments on: WD pitches Firewire pocket HDD

RE: Tar Dead 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 12:44 GMT

Coat

as title

Absolutely bonkers. 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 12:56 GMT

Thumb Down

Might well get a USB only one and save a few quid.

I've been switching to these small drives lately, since ditching the desktop. I'd be quite happy to pay a bit extra for firewire, but no point if it means having USB too.

Recently got a Toshiba USB that needs the juice from two USB ports. Seems to work well enough off one though (at least on the left side of the MBP, though not on the right side).

For PowerBook booting 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 13:09 GMT

I think the old PowerPC laptops like the PowerBook were only able to boot off firewire and not usb. Maybe WD just wanted to cover all the bases.

Ridiculous 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 13:21 GMT

Stop

Well, count me out then. That's really not very well thought out, is it?

Dollar gaining strength? 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 14:05 GMT

Pirate

And check out the Dollar/Pound conversion.

Do WD know something about the future of exchange rates we don't?

Jolly Roger for piracy across the high seas of the Atlantic.

@Hywel Thomas 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 14:06 GMT

That's simply because 2.5" drives should beable to be powered from USB ports, but in some case's there just isn't neough power, specially in certain laptops. Dell are (or were, not sure now?) bad for this.

I had one that couldn't power 2.5" drives... what sucks, is I have a cable with 2 usb ends, but only 1 usb port!

The above, sounds like lazy/cheap manufacturing to me.

no thx 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 14:06 GMT

Wow they produce a drive that maybe 9/10 people would like, then cripple it in a way that will turn off 9/10 of potential buyers. In today's mature portable hard-drive markets, it sounds a waste of shelf space.

DOH! 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 14:30 GMT

Thumb Down

Another product developed by the marketingtards and not by people who have a clue (and are probably paid less!)

Stick with Iomega 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 15:33 GMT

Thumb Down

I have a portable Iomega HD which is equally happy being powered by the Firewire port, a single USB port when plugged into a USB 2.0 port, two ports on the off chance that you need to plug it into a USB 1.1 port, or a 5V DC power adapter.

It also came with all those cables in the box, unlike my recently-acquired Epson printer which came with a power lead but no USB cable. Thinking it was a mistake, I looked at the bit of paper showing the package contents, and sure enough there was no USB cable shown.

@simon 

Posted Thursday 22nd May 2008 17:48 GMT

The USB specs limit the current a device can request to a max of 500mA. This sets an upper limit on the power a USB port can supply. Its not a bug to only output this.