Cardboard mixed with razor blades and ball bearings #
By Anonymous CowardPosted Wednesday 9th July 2008 18:56 GMT
Does anyone else think popcorn is about as nice as chewing on cardboard? I can't see the continuing appeal of the snack. It seems to me that cinemas only sell popcorn to sell drinks as it's mercilessly dry stuff. The fragments of skin from the kernels is like little razor blades slicing at your gums and firmly wedging itself between your teeth. Then there are the unpopped or semi-popped kernels hiding in there just waiting to cause an unplanned trip to the dentist.
More careful reading would've revealed that nobody said "there isn't enough power on USB to run that light bulb", rather "do that" would obviously be the end result reported about.
Further, if you ran a 2.8V bulb off 5V it'll use more than 0.3a and immediately burn out so obviously it was further current limited. Given a concentrated enough heat it could pop a little but not enough to make it worth the effort or have a snack in a reasonable amount of time.
The disappointing part is to generate more heat to do it instead of using the waste heat from the proceessor. Mount a little aluminum pot with copper bottom over the processoor and you'd have a more suitable and more green popcorn maker, if only you found the load level that keeps the CPU from frying itself.
naah, the movie would be over by the time all the popcorn has popped, besides I'm having trouble believing it actually works because there's a cut in the middle of the video clip where suddenly it's full of popcorn, whereas I CAN believe this USB powered meat cooker is real, granted it does use the power from 30 USB ports...
By Anonymous CowardPosted Thursday 10th July 2008 02:28 GMT
The details of the light bulb etc are irrelevant. The spec for USB is to provide a maximum of 2.5 Watts. Corn kernels need to be raised to a nominal 150C (300F) for enough pressure to build inside from the internal moisture to "pop". So the issue is whether the can can be insulated enough for 2.5W to raise the kernels to 150C.
USB is spec'ed to provide at least 2.5 watts (.5A at 5V) but any individual implementation is free to provide more. Still the question remains how much power is required to get the bottom plate of this device to the required 400 degree F to pop the corn.
Any kernel directly in contact with the light bulb might get hot enough to pop, but I doubt the rest would go without a lot of shaking to get each one in turn to touch the bulb.
They poured a small amount of liquid (vegetable oil?) in too; that might have helped transfer heat from the bulb to the kernel.
Also, I reckon the grey gunk was metal-loaded epoxy, not thermal grease. I wouldn't want to eat silicone grease...
By Anonymous CowardPosted Thursday 10th July 2008 08:21 GMT
Ah, if only it was running Linux- it'd have a far better Kernel!
Actually there were clearly two bulbs in series... #
By Bob FPosted Thursday 10th July 2008 09:06 GMT
...which would work pretty well off 5 volts.
Power consumption would be in the region of 1.5 watts.
Even assuming:
- 100% efficiency on power transfer to heat within the can
- the system was isolated and within a vacuum
- specific heat capacity of steel as 500 J/kg C
- steel can mass of 100 grammes
by my calculation it would take about an hour and a quarter to increase the temperature of the can by 130 degrees C from a nominal room temperature of 20 degrees C.
In reality the system would reach equilibrium at much lower than that, although there may be localised points at the base of the can that reach the temperature required to pop one or two kernels.
By jubtastic1Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 09:59 GMT
The 2 bulbs were sealed into a jar cap that was in turn glued onto the bottom of the tin can, the majority of the heat generated by the bulbs would be trapped and transfer through the bottom of the can where gravity holds corn kernels against the hot parts with oil added for better heat transfer.
The whole can doesn't have to hit 150C and the 'Thermal grease' is on the outside of the can and so doesn't come into contact with the popcorn.
I note an insulator/reflector added to the jar cap, the fact that we can clearly see corn popping before he puts the jar over the top (and while in place), and that on pouring out the popcorn the base of the can shows heat discolouration. Looks like he shockingly cut out ten minutes of cooking time, which is a shame as that would have put this short film right up there with the You Tube classics "my kettle boiling" and "paint drying on sunny day"
Not Fake but I doubt those bulbs would operate for very long making for some expensive pop corn regardless*
*and yet still cheaper than you can buy it at the cinema.
Comments on: Man powers up PC to pop popcorn
Cardboard mixed with razor blades and ball bearings #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 9th July 2008 18:56 GMT
Not a Stir Crazy.. #
By Damn Yank Posted Wednesday 9th July 2008 20:39 GMT
How does a fake like this gets into El Reg?? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 9th July 2008 21:28 GMT
Paraphrasing Homer Simpson: #
By Michael Habel Posted Wednesday 9th July 2008 22:15 GMT
@ How does a fake [...] #
By Ryan Posted Wednesday 9th July 2008 22:32 GMT
@ Ryan #
By JC Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 00:33 GMT
2.5 watt popcorn maker? #
By Haku Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 01:30 GMT
Forest from the trees #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 02:28 GMT
Film fanatics?! #
By David Wiernicki Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 03:03 GMT
And yet... #
By Shaun Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 03:41 GMT
USB spec #
By easyk Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 03:41 GMT
Re: How does a fake ... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 07:05 GMT
@"Further, if you ran a 2.8V bulb off 5V it'll use more than 0.3a" #
By Clive Galway Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 07:09 GMT
Must be fake #
By GettinSadda Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 08:01 GMT
The first few would pop #
By andy_p Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 08:20 GMT
Don't need a title... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 08:21 GMT
Actually there were clearly two bulbs in series... #
By Bob F Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 09:06 GMT
Jebus, did I watch a different video? #
By jubtastic1 Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 09:59 GMT
So... #
By Kane Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 11:43 GMT
Ah, popcorn... #
By Graham Marsden Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 12:26 GMT
By my calculations. #
By Chris Ellis Posted Thursday 10th July 2008 12:30 GMT