By AndrewPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 11:54 GMT
I don't see anything in that picture that differentiates it from any other laptop I've seen inside. So the memory and hard disk can be upgraded, and other peripherals are installed in standard slots. Am I missing something?
By David RollinsonPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:11 GMT
I think the point is that these components are accessible from a simple panel on the base of the unit. AFAIK some of the current crop of SCCs have to be completely dismantled to change the memory module or SSD unit.
Presumably this is to enable Dell's usual policy of "customised at the factory" to be relatively easy with the 910.
By SimonPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:19 GMT
The first thing I would hack would be the second row of the keyboard to put the keys back where they're supposed to be (instead of right above the third row).
How annoying is typing on that going to be? It would drive me mad in no time.
By Nigel WrightPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:38 GMT
I've just tested the MSI Wind for the last 2 weeks and I reckon it's a superb device bar the lack of access to the internals and the battery life. Overall it's a quality experience and the best "scc" so far imo in terms of performance, build and usability. If the Dell can better that...
Aldi (cheapo supermarket in the UK) have just released a clone of the Wind, badged by Medion for £279 as opposed to the Wind's £349. Now that's worth looking at.
By Tom SmithPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:18 GMT
To add 1Gb of ram to my Acer Aspire One, I had to remove all of the screws, the keyboard, the metal shield under the keyboard, more screws, and finally flip the mother board out and stick the RAM in.
Then a day later I had to take most of it apart again because I'd disturbed the SSD cable and was getting intermittent read/write errors.
So yes, an easily accessible DIMM slot is a big deal, (and yes I wish I'd waited a few more weeks).
By MonkeyPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:27 GMT
...They have quite a noticeable weight advantage and are just that bit smaller to feasibly be chucked into any old bag along with all your other crap and you not have to consider any dedicated bag for them.
You're right, it is only marginal size wise but it's enough and the weight saving from the cut down peripherals means you REALLY don't notice what you're carrying. I was of exactly the same opinion as you until I used one for a couple of weeks and as long as you use them for what they are intended (ultra portability), and accept the limitations of the hardware, they can be something of a minor revelation.
By HakuPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:06 GMT
...and I doubt you ever will considering you're unable to even identify the proper name of your own Acer Extensa 5420 laptop, which weighs 3 times that of these mini-laptops, has spining disc media which is susceptable to drops etc., and because the mini-laptops are significantly smaller and lighter they're far more portable & durable than a 'full-size' laptop will ever be.
By SimonPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:39 GMT
To add 1gb of ram to my Advent 4211, I had to remove some screws, and the underside of my machine. Very easy indeed.
The extra 1gb of ram cost exactly £10 delivered from ebay from some dozy bird who had accidentally ordered it for her desktop machine.
I wouldn't touch Dell computer hardware with a very long barge-pole (with the exception of their excellent monitors). This laptot comes with 512mb of memory by standard which apparently can only be upgraded to a massive 1024mb maximum - is the motherboard really that poor?
I have no less/fewer? than 9 individual LEDs on my machine, it's quite useful to know when advanced 21st century features such as Caps Lock have been enabled or the HDD is accessing. I shall naturally be upgrading the hard-drive in due course to store my excessive pr0n collection.
By SimonPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:42 GMT
That's probably why you don't have one then.... Mine fits in the glove tray of my car or in my mini backpack if I'm out and about. Very useful for me indeed.
@Nathan Hobbs, PCW Business, and the Advent 4211 #
By Anonymous CowardPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:59 GMT
> Don't forget the MSI Wind is available from PC World Business as the Adver^Hnt 4211 for only £218 plus £10 delivery.
I think 'available' is possibly an exaggeration! I've been checking the web page http://www.pcwb.com/catalogue/item/ADVNB027 for over a week now, and unwaveringly it says "Availability: 0 in stock".
Advent 4211: needs a 6 cell battery and a 16GB SSD.
Aspire One: Ditto.
EEE 901: needs to be £30-50 cheaper and get a better keyboard.
Inspiron 910: needs to come in at <£250 with 1GB RAM (expandable to 2GB) and have a battery life of 4+ hours (and gain some LED lights if there's no quick on-screen check).
Until one of the above happens, I'll keep the cash cheers.
I suspect that I'll be disappointed again (tomorrow?).
By Britt JohnstonPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 15:54 GMT
The idea of marking the alternative characters is useful, until the ink rubs off. Having a non-standard keyboard means they can feel free to improve previous iterations; set <CTRL><ALT/GR>4 to £ or € for example.
For serious writing or coding, I'd be plugging in a USB keyboard on all SCCs.
By Lennart SorensenPosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 20:46 GMT
The point of these small things, at least the way Asus has done them, is that they run Linux, from SSD, boot in seconds (not minutes, the way windows does), which means you will actually whip it out, check your email, and put it away, all in half the time it would take your normal laptop to boot windows.
They are not meant as laptop replacements, they don't do everything, they just happen to be the fastest and most convenient way to check email or a web page if you happen to be at the coffee shop with wifi access and the urge to check something.
That is why Asus apparently sells 5 times as many Linux EeePCs as Windows XP models. The windows one takes minutes to boot and defeats the entire purpose of being quick and convenient and always with you,
Re: The point of these things / Lennart Sorensen #
By dabotsonlinePosted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 23:11 GMT
"That is why Asus apparently sells 5 times as many Linux EeePCs as Windows XP models."
I want an SCC as a secondary machine, ('S')mall enough to surf on the sofa with pretty much full functionality (that's the second 'C' - for computer), take on the train to work and pack for weekends away etc. if I want. But I don't need another primary machine, and it's associated cost (and there's the middle 'C').
At the £200-£250 price point they fill the gap between mobile/PDA (lacking in second 'C') and 'decent' 13"+ laptop (lacking in 'S' and middle 'C').
My primary machine is an M1330 laptop. As far as I can see, desktops are only really necessary for avid gamers or upgraders these days.
Saving a few seconds with Linux is a bonus, but I can't do what I need with Linux (without spending those_few_seconds_saved^10 on researching and implementing Linux hacks and workarounds), so there's no point booting it up in the first place. Waiting for XP to boot is a drag, but I'm not in so much of a hurry that that single factor defines my choice of OS.
By Michael DukePosted Thursday 4th September 2008 01:36 GMT
In NZ the Acer 5420 was an Aspire not a Extensa. In fact the Extensa range has only been available in NZ for about a week or two.
Back on topic I will be looking at this as I want a SCC but none of the current machines have convinced me yet. The EeePC 901 would probably do what I want but it does not have quite enough storage.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Thursday 4th September 2008 07:54 GMT
It's out but £299 as a starting price, more if you want a 2 year warranty. Dell have missed the point slightly as the cheapest Dell non submini notebook is only £25 more.
1gb Ram 120GB hdd and xp home. Not bad but your paying the Dell name tax.
By Ted TreenPosted Thursday 4th September 2008 08:30 GMT
Nope, I wouldn't buy one either:-
1) I'm a Mac person (fanboy, even)
2) It wouldn't suit my needs
But then, I wouldn't buy a MacBook Air - for reason 2) either.
However, I can accept that this (and the Air) are machines designed to address a specific market area. I would not denigrate them just because I happen to be outside that area.
They're both good machines - if they address your specific needs: if they don't - then don't knock them, but buy what does.
1/ EEE 901 (£280, ebuyer) needs to be £30 cheaper. Has n Wi-fi. 6cell 6600mAh beats all comers. 4GB less SSD than Mini 9.
2/ Mini 9 (£300, Dell) seems to have a marginally better keyboard and a nice looking (XPS M1330-esque?) touchpad, but needs to be £50 cheaper. Battery of 4+ hours unlikely? Free delivery puts it in with a shout of the top spot.
3/ 4211/Medion/Wind (£280, PCW) needs to be £30 cheaper, needs SSD instead of 80GB SSD, better battery and it's old touchpad back. Props for the keyboard and 10" screen though. NB: PCWB have put the price up from £235 but are still out of stock so that looks like a gone-er).
4/ Aspire One (£280, dabs) needs to be £30 cheaper, needs a better battery, has 120GB HDD but no Windows SSD option. It's touchpad is small and 'non-standard'. No Bluetooth. Difficult to upgrade.
Looks are entirely subjective, and none are really munters by any score.
If you look a litle closer, it currently costs (just checked again online to be sure) £279.99 from PC World but no delivery available, so you have to go to the shop, or it costs £271.41 plus deliver from PCWB (have to add on the VAT for the average mad in the street who cant claim his VAT back). Roughly about the same cost I would say. Depends on if you happen to be near a PC World store ...
Still along way from the original cost of £218 plus delivery from the original post ... that would have been a really good price.
Back to the original story - there is a load of bad feeling on the forums about how badly Dell has acted regarding releasing even initial specs and availability on the 910. Shame, I'm in the market for at least one and having tried most of them out, I don't really like any of them enough to part with my cash yet.
By kevinPosted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:44 GMT
looking a "W"'s commens on SCC, i get by with a 12" screen, proper keyboard, 1.6kg weight, 3-4 hours battery life, 1024x768 screen, wifi, USB2, 60Gb drive. and all for £200 - £250. i went and bought another two for the kids. they're called IBM X31.
By Anonymous CowardPosted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:48 GMT
"Inspiron Mini 9" - but, being an Inspiron, it's down as "Home User" only.
But... £299
OK, so it's "home", so at least that price includes VAT & delivery, and there's no options other than 1 or 2yr (£29) warranty. 1.6GHz Atom, 16Gb SSD, 1Gb RAM, 2200Ah battery, XP.
Comments on: Dell Inspiron 910 mini-laptop to be a hardware hacker's dream?
WWAN + WLAN + SoftAP #
By David Hicks Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 11:50 GMT
Hacker's dream? #
By Andrew Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 11:54 GMT
No lights? #
By Wortel Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 11:54 GMT
re. Hackers dream #
By David Rollinson Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:11 GMT
Keyboard?? #
By Simon Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:19 GMT
I hope it's as good as or better than the Wind. #
By Nigel Wright Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:38 GMT
Sigh #
By Sam Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:41 GMT
i still dont see the point of these laptops #
By Matthew Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:42 GMT
re: keyboard #
By John Robson Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 12:59 GMT
William Hill #
By Dale Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:00 GMT
Minor correction #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:11 GMT
re: Hackers Dream #
By Tom Smith Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:18 GMT
@ Matthew #
By Monkey Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:27 GMT
Re: William Hill #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:34 GMT
many questions.. #
By Parax Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:36 GMT
MSI Wind = £218 #
By Nathan Hobbs Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:45 GMT
Re: I still don't see the point in these laptops #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 13:52 GMT
Re: i still dont see the point of these laptops #
By Haku Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:06 GMT
No backslash backlash after all #
By W Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:22 GMT
But there might be... #
By W Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:26 GMT
re: Hackers Dream #
By Simon Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:39 GMT
re: i still dont see the point of these laptops #
By Simon Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:42 GMT
@Nathan Hobbs, PCW Business, and the Advent 4211 #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 14:59 GMT
Nearly there. #
By W Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 15:10 GMT
@Simon #
By William Old Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 15:17 GMT
@Nathan Hobbs, PCW Business, and the Advent 4211 #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 15:40 GMT
risqué ASCII ( = display test ) #
By Britt Johnston Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 15:54 GMT
OSX #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 17:45 GMT
Toshiba's coming to the party too #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 19:22 GMT
The point of these things #
By Lennart Sorensen Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 20:46 GMT
Re: The point of these things / Lennart Sorensen #
By dabotsonline Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 23:11 GMT
mobile vs netbook #
By W Posted Wednesday 3rd September 2008 23:40 GMT
RE: Haku #
By Michael Duke Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 01:36 GMT
@Matthew #
By WonkoTheSane Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 05:07 GMT
I like 'W's' Analysis of Need and His Decision Tree #
By Monkey Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 06:43 GMT
Out but too expensive #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 07:54 GMT
Balanced response #
By Ted Treen Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 08:30 GMT
Now available. #
By W Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:19 GMT
Not enough profit margin, eh? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:23 GMT
@Nathan Hobbs, PCW Business, and the Advent 4211 #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:25 GMT
erm IBM thinkpad X31 anyone? #
By kevin Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:44 GMT
Well, it's on Dell.co.uk now... #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 4th September 2008 09:48 GMT