By James Pickett (Jp)Posted Monday 8th September 2008 12:57 GMT
The streaming on the ipod touch looks very nice, so a nice bonus feature for N96 users.
It's a shame they didn't give Touch users the option to download though, as I'd really only use it out and about!
iPhone only allows streaming with a Wifi connection #
By Iain CrollPosted Monday 8th September 2008 13:02 GMT
So although it sounds great - it's actually not that useful. If I have a wifi connection most of the time that's for a short period at a cafe or something either that or I'm at home - in which case I'll use my laptop with the 13" screen over the iPhone
By Tim CookPosted Monday 8th September 2008 13:16 GMT
The BBC made Iplayer compatible with the Iphone a year ago - has it really taken them a year to add one other phone to that list?
Why is this application specific to the N96, and not S60/Symbian phones in general (of which there are about a squillion)? What about other platforms like Windows Mobile - developing an Iplayer app for either S60 or WM would add many more users overnight.
The Iplayer is a license-fee funded service, and should not be used as a niche feature in the marketing of one or two high-profile products like the Iphone and N96. Either make it a truly mobile service available to as many different phones as possible, or just don't bother - leave it as web only!
By Anonymous CowardPosted Monday 8th September 2008 14:36 GMT
Maybe because there's more people with a Symbian mobile phone than there are who use Linux ??
Are you 100% sure about this ?
Symibian mobile phone users who actually use it for net too ? ahem i doubt this to be a real factor
Most of these people carrying these phones are doing it to impress their mates more than likely they would use their PC to browse web than a 2 inch screen to browse
For all you bafoons out there when the net came out there was 3 platforms Windblows Linux and Macs
Good Software creators Create for all 3 bad s/w writers make it for what they use and ignore rest..
Regardless of wether i use Linux or windblows I pay tv license so hey for my money i would also like to view BBCILacker on my Linux Desktop Cos I will refuse to support Microsoft
By Andy NugentPosted Monday 8th September 2008 14:42 GMT
The N96 is S60 3.0 feature pack 2 and has added support for WMV9, so I'm guessing one of these means that it won't work on earlier models (probably the WMV9 support).
By BennyPosted Monday 8th September 2008 14:53 GMT
From what I got from this article this is just for N96 phones, not Symbian phones on a whole. In which case im fairly sure that there would be more OSX/Linux computers out there than N96 phones.
By Tim CookPosted Monday 8th September 2008 14:53 GMT
The N96 is the latest Nokia S60 phone, but I'm not aware of any great advance in S60 itself that makes this phone capable of using Iplayer while the others weren't. S60 is well established and has long been capable of dealing with all manner of multimedia, and DRM for that matter.
Windows Mobile is still completely ignored and Iplayer-less, despite having Windows Media support built in - why?
It just seems the BBC are only interested in jumping on high-profile bandwagons and pushing the sales of new phones rather than actually providing a public service. You just know they'll have an Iplayer support for Android before the first Dream has left the factory, and yet the perfectly capable phones that TV licence holders have in their pockets right now are being ignored. Why?
By Matt WhitePosted Monday 8th September 2008 15:39 GMT
Dammit, I'm thinking about getting a Samsung i8510, which runs Symbian S60 FP2. Exactly the same as the N96. The Beeb should be looking at making the iPlayer available for the operating system, rather than for each specific hardware model.
Can you imagine if they came out and said it was now available for the Dell Studio Hybrid?
By Richard HodgsonPosted Tuesday 9th September 2008 08:00 GMT
Seems like a massive waste of development time if they're only going to allow this to work with the Nokia N96. There are a ton of Symbian S60 phones out there, including Nokia's own very popular N95 series, that would benefit from this.
I know that it creates an additional marketing point for the N96, but there's nothing like screwing over current customers to put them off buying your product in the future.
By Phil LewisPosted Tuesday 9th September 2008 22:16 GMT
I think that my blog post here: http://linuxcentre.net/?p=16 may shed some light on the upcoming N96 download service. I've determined that the stream appears to be H.264 128kbps video and AAC 64kbps. The streaming protocol is RTSP with a 3GP container. The resolution is 320x176.
I've already had it streaming and downloading on Linux with vlc and I've had others report it works out-of-the-box on several other devices including mobiles and windows :-)
I could be looking at the completely wrong stream but it seems likely to be the right one.
Comments on: Beeb readies iPlayer app for Nokia N96
ipod #
By James Pickett (Jp) Posted Monday 8th September 2008 12:57 GMT
iPhone only allows streaming with a Wifi connection #
By Iain Croll Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:02 GMT
Why #
By Tim Cook Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:16 GMT
How about #
By Benny Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:21 GMT
make one for WM phones #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:27 GMT
so its windows and mobiles ? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:28 GMT
re: How about #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 8th September 2008 13:43 GMT
@Tim Cook #
By Karim Bourouba Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:17 GMT
iPlayer doesn't work on Mac? #
By Richard Kilpatrick Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:36 GMT
re re: How about #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:36 GMT
re: Why #
By Andy Nugent Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:42 GMT
@re: How about #
By Benny Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:53 GMT
@Karim Bourouba #
By Tim Cook Posted Monday 8th September 2008 14:53 GMT
S60 FP2 or N96? #
By Matt White Posted Monday 8th September 2008 15:39 GMT
@Tim Cook #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Monday 8th September 2008 16:21 GMT
Wot? N96 only?! #
By Richard Hodgson Posted Tuesday 9th September 2008 08:00 GMT
Download the stream NOW! #
By Phil Lewis Posted Tuesday 9th September 2008 22:16 GMT