Reg Hardware

Comments on: Qantas phone check-in to take off next year

Over the top 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 17:01 GMT

What's the point of the Barcode. Finnair for one has had SMS-based check-in for years without the need to limit the service to phones that can display 2D barcodes. User ID + the SMS is enough. 2D barcodes Sound like a case of over design and limiting of user base.

Air Canada has been using this for over a year... 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 17:10 GMT

...as far as I know, you can use it for any domestic Air Canada flights. All of the major airports, at any rate: Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, Ottawa, Calgary, Halifax, etc. It's been quite handy. Too bad they won't let us use it on US-bound flights.

Over the top indeed - why need a token at all? 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 18:32 GMT

Thumb Down

As ze said, this is over the top. I don't actually see the need for any special single-use user token at all in almost all cases. For international flights you have to provide ID when booking the flight these days anyway. And most people use a credit card even for domestic flights. So just show up with your passport or credit card and they check you in. Several airlines do this already, actually.

I suppose this would be useful for people who book flights for which they don't need to provide ID, and pay with cash - that's a lot of people...

BMI do this 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 23:31 GMT

Thumb Up

I travelled from Edinburgh to London yesterday on BMI with one of these "boarding passes".

It's a bit bizarre, actually: at security, and at the gate, they put the barcode under their scanner to validate it. When you get on the plane itself, the steward(ess) wants to do a visual inspection of the barcode (as well as the text part of the message). What (s)he hopes to learn from that, I'm not sure.

As Adam says, above, though, it does seem a solution in search of a problem. Tying my boarding to a plastic card already in my wallet would be soooo much easier.

@Adam Williamson 

Posted Saturday 13th September 2008 00:35 GMT

It's not about the check-in process, it's all about boarding the plane. QANTAS has had online check-in for domestic flights for ages, the usual stuff that a lot of airlines have: check-in, seat selection, baggage advice and the like. Once checked-in you then got a boarding pass either from the airport or printed at home (again, nothing cutting edge). It is the boarding pass ("single user token" if you like) that is scanned to positively verify that the checked-in pax boarded the plane. This process is, I understand, an IATA requirement and it is for this purpose that the barcode-on-a-screen will be used.

Continental Airlines already does IT 

Posted Saturday 13th September 2008 03:52 GMT

Continental has been doing the cell phone check it for a few months now and no need to scan.

Tech looking for a solution 

Posted Sunday 14th September 2008 21:04 GMT

Flame

I have one of the 2d bar code scanners. Its a technology looking for a solution. I'm guessing it takes about twice as long to get a good read as the paper scanners that Qantas already uses. The things only work with a fraction of new phones with the glossy ones being the worst. Its also going to cost $.20 at least for Qantas to send the MMS message if they get the super discount rate and the failure rate for sending those tends to be in the 5% range depending on the carrier. Getting a hundred+ people to find a specific message on their phone will be fun. Telstra has been pushing these 2d bar codes since they have to appear to be doing something technological to their stock holders. There is no where for this project to go except down.

Gee 

Posted Sunday 14th September 2008 21:45 GMT

Telephone checkin ? It's almost like the 1980s again.