By Anonymous CowardPosted Saturday 11th October 2008 11:22 GMT
Looks nice but this (and your earlier reviews of internet radios) need more detail about how they work.
I know that most internet radios use firmware from Reciva.com. This depends on getting listings and URLs of stations and on-demand streams from the Reciva site. If the web site goes down (admittedly, it's happened to me once in a year) you're stuck with your pre-sets or whatever you listened to last.
Overall, I like my Reciva-based radio but it has plenty of annoyances, especially in the layout of the menus. For instance, why put the network setup (which you may only use once) at the top of the menu but the sleep timer (which you may use daily) eighth? Also, it's irritating that podcasts restart as soon as they've finished playing and will do so ad infinitum until interrupted by the user.
It would be interesting to know whether other models suffer from similar irritations. Is this one Reciva-based or does it get its firmware and URLs from another source? If it doesn't use Reciva, is it equally dependent on another web site?
By Tony HoylePosted Saturday 11th October 2008 13:38 GMT
AC, it's a DAB device, not an internet radio. It's dependent on the continued broadcast of DAB (which should continue for a few years unless the BBC drop it).
By Anonymous CowardPosted Saturday 11th October 2008 16:30 GMT
I think you need to read the review a little more closely!
"The Pico RadioStation is again claimed to be a world-first: the only truly portable hybrid radio to unite DAB and DAB+, RDS FM, internet radio, and content streaming abilities"
furthermore -
"The internet search menu is nice and simple, and also has a section of FAQs for internet radio beginners. It provides easy-to follow genre- and location-based searche tempates, and the ever weirder world of podcasts is put on an easy-to-digest plate."
It's even got an FM tuner. Should be good for a few years yet.
By TanukiPosted Saturday 11th October 2008 20:02 GMT
£170 for a 'single drive unit' - sorry - *mono* as the rest-of-the-world-calls-it radio?
Pull the other one please.
Channel-4 have in the last week pulled out of the whole DAB game.
DAB audio quality sucks; it's significantly worse than FM.
Why would anyone sane blow significant money on any mono DAB-thing when they can get a proper stereo FM radio for under a tenner at the local car-boot-sale/street-market?
By MarkPosted Saturday 11th October 2008 20:37 GMT
I have a Pico WiFi - predecessor of this unit. It has not been without its problems; I am on my second unit having needed a replacement due to a hard hang problem. The Reciva Internet radio system is far from perfect; there are too many duplicate entries, and the categories provided don't really reflect the range of content that's available.
But it's a nice little unit, and this new version seems like it is a step forwards. I'd have one.
I'm a news junkie: lots of news stations are not on FM. But I cannot for love or money buy a decent portable media device that does AM *and* MP3+FM! This is very irritating!
Also, how does broadcast work in the UK? It seem that there is a gov't or quasi-gov't body called OFCOM that dictates whether a manufacturer's products can work. Is this correct? In Canada we have the CRTC which licenses broadcast outfits but generally does not license makers of reception equipment. Why would you want to control what products can receive broadcasts?
This is very strange. Can anyone explain it to me?
Thanks in advance!
The penguin because I sometimes listen to CBC webcasts on my Linux box.
By Henry WertzPosted Sunday 12th October 2008 22:33 GMT
"In Canada we have the CRTC which licenses broadcast outfits but generally does not license makers of reception equipment. Why would you want to control what products can receive broadcasts?"
Britain has TV license fees, and had a radio license fee up through the 1970s. So really I think there'd be no point but I assume it's vestigial from when they did want to keep track.
By gizmo23Posted Monday 13th October 2008 08:19 GMT
It's a portable radio. It will play for about 12 hours on battery and has covered ports so you don't have to worry too much about dirt and water.
OK, so how big is it?
An important piece of information for a portable unit, I reckon. After all there's a big deal of difference between a radio the size of my phone and one that's as big as a juice carton, say. All the relevant information please, next time!
By Simon WardPosted Monday 13th October 2008 09:06 GMT
"The problem with stereo FM radios picked up for under a tenner at car-boots is that they can't receive the cricket commentary."
Well, they probably can if you can get Five Live. However, it sounds like you're probably one of the Luddites like me who prefers TMS on Radio 4 long-wave :-)
DAB is all fine and well, if and when it works, and even then it is far from perfect. In the middle of Swansea it works fairly well, but go a mile or two west (not even as far as Llanelli), and you can't get anything, although apparently it does work in parts of Llanelli.
The local radio stations only broadcast live sports commentry on MW which my DAB radio doesn't pick up - so if I want to listen to the commentry from the Osprey's game then it is back out with my £5 Tesco value FM/AM radio. Apart from Virgin/Absolute I don't know of any MW/LW stations that are available on DAB.
By Richard PorterPosted Monday 13th October 2008 10:59 GMT
Although it has a USB port for software upgrades, there is no front mounted USB port that you can plug a pen drive into for playing music or storing incoming programmes. A lot of talking newspapers for the blind are now switching from cassettes to pen drives for distribution, as well as internet in some cases. Can the Pico log onto password protected streaming/podcast sites?
Mono, poor quality, limited reception, extremely expensive - what are they trying to sell you? A worse experience than a 1930's valve radio? The word 'digtal' really has become synonymous with shite.
Comments on: Revo Pico RadioStation DAB+ radio
Nice #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 10:29 GMT
More detail please! #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 11:22 GMT
@AC #
By Tony Hoyle Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 13:38 GMT
Internet Radio?? #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 16:25 GMT
@Tony Hoyle #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 16:30 GMT
@Tony Hoyle #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 17:25 GMT
@Tony Hoyle #
By John Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 17:46 GMT
Ewww... #
By Tanuki Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 20:02 GMT
Evolution of the Pico WiFi #
By Mark Posted Saturday 11th October 2008 20:37 GMT
Nice… #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Sunday 12th October 2008 02:11 GMT
What about AM, also... #
By E Posted Sunday 12th October 2008 05:47 GMT
@Tanuki #
By Anonymous Coward Posted Sunday 12th October 2008 18:54 GMT
License fee #
By Henry Wertz Posted Sunday 12th October 2008 22:33 GMT
portable radio #
By gizmo23 Posted Monday 13th October 2008 08:19 GMT
Re: @Tanuki #
By Simon Ward Posted Monday 13th October 2008 09:06 GMT
DAB isn't all that it is cracked up to be #
By Tom Posted Monday 13th October 2008 10:23 GMT
What about USB? #
By Richard Porter Posted Monday 13th October 2008 10:59 GMT
'OOOOOOW MUCH?! #
By Simon B Posted Monday 13th October 2008 12:20 GMT
Count Arthur Strong #
By Jonathan Posted Monday 13th October 2008 12:27 GMT
looks like this isn't a Reciva radio #
By Anna Log Posted Monday 13th October 2008 13:17 GMT
What are they trying to sell you? #
By druck Posted Monday 13th October 2008 13:34 GMT
I thought this was a RadioStation #
By Wayland Sothcott Posted Monday 13th October 2008 13:49 GMT