By John LathamPosted Monday 23rd February 2009 13:43 GMT
This is a bundle, not an integrated solution. I have some of those Devolo Homeplug devices, and whilst they work well, they are heavy and bulky.
A proper integrated solution would stick the powerline electronics inside the box, and use a normal plug to provide both power and connectivity with a single cable.
In reality they are unlicensed transmitters, getting CE mark under the wrong regulations. Mains wiring is not shielded, screened, coaxial or twisted pair. These things radiate a huge amount of RF outside the home destroying MF & HF reception of analogue and newer DRM services.
For people too lazy or mean to run CAT5 cable in many cases.
By Simon WardPosted Monday 23rd February 2009 23:30 GMT
"For people too lazy or mean to run CAT5 cable"
Or those people who live/work in buildings which were built at a time when the construction material was brick and/or stone rather than snot and sawdust.
Never underestimate the attenuation properties of a couple of good, solid courses of brickwork.
By MagePosted Tuesday 24th February 2009 09:09 GMT
Yes there are occassions where this is needed because WiFi won't work or cables are difficult.
I alluded to that in the OP.
But we do need proper standards testing of these, which doesn't exist. At the end of the day if the designers can't make them work correctly then we need a different solution. The Radio Spectrum is assigned and protected by National laws and International treaty.
It may be that these need an allocated band. Or limited to the difficult buildings (which often block the transmissions from leaving the building).
Most people don't need them. They do pollute the Spectrum, especially some models/makes. Since some are much worse than others it suggests the correct standards and testing is not getting applied.
By Tony Smith, Editor, Reg HardwarePosted Tuesday 24th February 2009 11:18 GMT
This is no longer an issue - and hasn't been for quite some time. All powerline kit, irrespective of standard, is designed to avoid frequencies that will cause interference for, say, shortwave radio.
The origins of this problem lie in the early broadband-over-mains-cabling technology which preceded powerline ethernet. This *did* cause interference in certain frequencies, and so did some very early powerline products. But this was dealt with, and powerline adaptors now avoid those frequencies.
This is why Ofcom - which only reletively recently legalised FM transmitters for MP3 players - has never got stroppy with powerline equipment makers. It no longer needs to.
Comments on: Devolo dLAN AVEasy Wireless G
Missed opportunity #
By John Latham Posted Monday 23rd February 2009 13:43 GMT
EMC #
By Mage Posted Monday 23rd February 2009 15:34 GMT
@John Latham #
By Steve Foster Posted Monday 23rd February 2009 18:35 GMT
"For people too lazy or mean to run CAT5 cable " #
By Rick Axon Posted Monday 23rd February 2009 18:43 GMT
Re: EMC #
By Simon Ward Posted Monday 23rd February 2009 23:30 GMT
"in many cases" #
By Mage Posted Tuesday 24th February 2009 09:09 GMT
@Mage #
By Tony Smith, Editor, Reg Hardware Posted Tuesday 24th February 2009 11:18 GMT