Reg Hardware

Answers to: What's the best NAS-to-TV box?

Sooooo Many choices..... 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 09:41 GMT

Go

A PS3 or Xbox360 can stream from a UPNP source (bot sure if your NAS has a UPNP server). Failing that your best bet (IMO) is to get an Apple TV or a nettop PC and install XBMC (it will install on either, check youtube for a how to on Apple TV). XBMC plays back most file types and will check with online databases to download DVD thumbnails for all your files.

Popcorn Hour A110 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 09:57 GMT

Thumb Up

I've read lots of great things about the Popcorn Hour A110. It handles almost all codecs, is upgradable, can be used as a bit torrent client, it can work from an internal hard drive or also access a NAS. If you put an internal hard drive in the Popcorn Hour it will also work as a NAS - the only problem being that it only takes one disk.

Also have you considered looking at the QNAP range of NAS. They seem very comprehensive, two of my friends have them and can't recommend them enough. I'm in the middle of rationalising my home IT and will be implementing a combination of a Popcorn Hour and QNAP NAS with necessary home powerline networking.

http://www.popcornhour.com/

http://www.qnap.com/

PS3 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 10:52 GMT

Thumb Up

As per title - with added benefit of being able to play games on it too should you so wish, many of which are available as free demo versions through the PS3 on-line store.

My Recommendations 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 11:28 GMT

Linux

If your TV has a PC input, why not just use your netbook?

For £159, the Acer Revo, with HDMI output looks like a good bet: http://www.play.com/PC/PCs/4-/9606798/Acer-Aspire-Revo-Intel-Atom-N230-1-6GHz-1GB-8GB-SSD-Linux-Desktop-PC/Product.html although I've heard they are still a bit noisy.

There is always the overpriced Eee Box.

Aleutia also do an interesting range of silent and small PCs: http://www.aleutia.com/products

Personally, I just buy second hand small form factor PCs for £50 from ebay, but they can be a bit noisy.

XBMC 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 13:45 GMT

Thumb Up

I have an xbox 360 and i used to stream from my linkstaion pro nas using twonky media as a upnp server and i worked pretty well, the 360 plays .avi .mp4. .mp3 .divx so not too bad. I sold my NAS recently and built a media server, i'm still using my 360 to stream but will be building a custom built mini itx htpc and putting XMBC on it. Download XMBC live cd and give it a try, it's fantastic, it looks amazing and plays a crap load of stuff.

I like the idea of the acer revo as it's cheap at £150 and is more upgradable than apple tv which is under powered and over priced.

Cheers

Ginge

An all in one solution 

Posted Monday 15th June 2009 16:05 GMT

There are several TVs now that will stream from DLNA devices. Take the new Samsung LED 7000 series for example. It can be CAT5ed into a router or through optional wireless adaptor. It will play a whole host of formats too, divx SD and HD, .mkv and mp4s.

Of course this does require the purchase of a new Kate Moss-ingly slim TV though...

Popcorn Hour A110 

Posted Tuesday 16th June 2009 08:52 GMT

Linux

you can pick one up on ebay from £150-£200 and be guaranteed that it'll play all of your media, in high def as well

BLOBbox: DVB-T + PVR + torrent + internet 

Posted Tuesday 16th June 2009 08:53 GMT

If you need a box with DVB-T and HDD PVR + all the features of a popcorn hour + free SDK with a developers community, take a look at the BLOBbox.

http://www.tvblobbox.com/ataglance.php

HDX1000 

Posted Tuesday 16th June 2009 10:14 GMT

Thumb Up

Also very similar to the PCH A100, check out www.networkedmediatank.com for more info on these devices.

I have a HDX and couldn't recommend it more!

Take note there are some media formats that devices like a PS3 and Xbox360 won't / don't support, and many with serious geekwork involved.

thumbs up for qnap 

Posted Tuesday 16th June 2009 10:18 GMT

Go

I use a qnap 209 pro II nas for storing the media, then access it via xbmc on multiple xboxes (standard definition) or xbox 360s (high definition) throughout the house. Totally painless.