Reg Hardware

Comments on: Samsung smartphone keyboard takes wing

Zaphod Beeblebrox.... 

Posted Wednesday 8th July 2009 23:55 GMT

Pirate

....must be alive and well working for Samsung.

Looks crude 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 01:09 GMT

FAIL

I have to say the best mobile keyboard I ever used was the Psion 5. The fold out clamshell design allowed for near full-size keys in a compact case. I would be tempted if someone brought out a phone or maybe compact netbook with that design today.

it is not a stylus: it's proboscis! 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 01:17 GMT

Jobs Halo

the Koreans DID IT AGAIN!

It is truly revolutionary: you use your nose on the touch screen.

3 hands? 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 01:30 GMT

FAIL

I come equiped as standard with opposable thumbs, they really are a fantastic feature.

With these I can cradle the phone using my fingers, and use my thumbs to type on the keypads.

you know what else has wings? 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 01:40 GMT

Paris Hilton

maxi pads.

It's all for trade shows... 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 02:42 GMT

Paris Hilton

...you have one well-proportioned honey cradling the unit (I mean, the phone) on her chest, while the user gets to do the typing on the keypad.

It'll sell like crazy.

PH, obviously, would be a fine first choice.

great idea! I have a suggestion. 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 04:23 GMT

Thumb Up

I hate those tiny and clumsy keyboards as well as the slowness of the virtual keyboard and its equally small size. Anyone over 40 will begin to appreciate the larger keyboard.

My concern:

If you use this on your lap and the smartphone is between your legs, it will fall to a bad angle as well as skew the keyboard seating.

My suggestion:

Why don't you add extending rods at the top of the phone or some other kind of "top of phone" extension to keep the phone flat and parallel to the keyboard. I would love to buy one if it had that kind of feature.

Alternatives 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 04:38 GMT

Having to put it down on a flat surface is a major drawback. If the 'wings' swing upward, the keys could be thumb-operated. Less efficient than full-fingered input, but better than tiny on-screen keys. For touch-typists, you could put the keys on the back of the device - easy to use, easy to hold, thumbs can manipulate the screen.

nokia 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 05:19 GMT

didnt nokia sell a phone with wings that folded out either side of the screen? it was crap!

@AC 02:42 GMT 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 06:11 GMT

You DO know of course that PH is an A-cup?

3 hands? 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 07:08 GMT

We've all managed to use a keyboard and mouse on our regular PC's for years with 2 hands, I don't see why we suddenly need 3 hands for this then.

If the Good Lord had intended us to interact efficiently with these devices we would have been Intelligently Designed with Bluetooth, ot at least a USB port...

Buzz Lightyear to the Rescue 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 07:28 GMT

Thumb Down

Anyone else see the resemblance? Honestly how long to think that keyboard will last before it breaks.

Didn't 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 07:29 GMT

Wasn't there already a Nokia that actually did this? I don't think the swung down, but the keyboard definately folded out from both sides, from behind the device.

Samsung usability of handheld gadgets 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 07:50 GMT

I have a Samsung tv and dvd player/HD recorder.

Quite nice hardware in itself, for the price, but both have dismally designed remote controls. The button which turns on teletext is miles away from the button which turns it off, for example, which is a pain. (Yes, some of us still use teletext) The 'play' button on the DVD remote sometimes does the right thing, other times you have to use the centre of the 5-way button constellation, all depending on context.

There are other horrors, too. Frankly, I have very low expectations about Samsung's usability drive, but live in hope. At least people will see this gadget before they buy it, unlike remote controls, which rarely become part of the sales talk at (e.g.) Dixons.

Missing the point 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:15 GMT

Go

Contributors so far have missed the point.

The 'wings' are to facilitate inter-office memos. You enter the co-ordinates on the large screen then launch the device into the air. The wings deploy and cruise between colleagues/offices delivering the missives before you can say 'Bob's yer Uncle".

Chitty Chitty Bang Bang 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:18 GMT

WTF?

Does anyone else think it was inspired by the old chitty chitty bang bang toys?

Fragile 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:38 GMT

FAIL

OK it's just a diagram but it looks to me like either of those two 'wings' would snap off altogether too easily if you didn't handle it with extreme kid gloves.

Prior art 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:48 GMT

The "wings"-type folding keyboard has been done before, on at least one of Nokia's phones (the E70 (2006), and I think there was at least one other). Not that it's a bad idea - I'd like to see it appear more often - but just not an especially new one.

Nokia 6820 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:50 GMT

Had a flip system which provided the same function.

Of course that's too old to be prior art, or is swinging different from flipping?

Or how about... 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:50 GMT

...having the back of the phone swivel round 90 degrees to form the wings? It would undoubtedly be more solid.

Warm up the Disney lawyers 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 08:51 GMT

Happy

To infinity and beyond!

This is going to be fun in A&E 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 09:01 GMT

".. well, you see, I always carry the phone in my trouser pocket and the keyboard flipped open.."

"And nobody told you just how strong that spring was?"

"No, owww. Can you stitch it back on, doc?"

"Hmm. We'll try. Nurse, NURSE, prep for another Samsung user. And stop laughing!"

Quality. I love designers with a sense of humour, I really do. They nearly got away with it too..

Didn't Nokia already do something like this? 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 09:04 GMT

It wasn't as big but the keyboard swung out to create a very weird shape.

Come back Psion, all is forgiven 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 09:19 GMT

Paris Hilton

JMiles is bang on above. How can it be that in the many years since the demise of the Series 5 and Revo no one, but no one, has advanced on Psion's keyboard technology? Even more baffling is why Psion have licenced the tech to anyone (other than Amstrad for that p¡ss poor Emailer thing).

The thought of an iPhone with a Revo keyboard has me salivating.

(Paris, because opening up a Psion was always a joy.)

I'm with JMiles Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 01:09 GMT 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 09:30 GMT

Thumb Up

I had a Psion Series 5 and it was without doubt the best compact keyboard I ever typed on. Nothing has come close to it in terms of phone/pdas. I also have a wireless mini Logitech keyboard (for my media center pc) that fails because its just that little bit too small.

The Psion 3G would get my vote!!!

Sanitary Towel 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 10:22 GMT

Happy

One for the girls then...

In recent news ... 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 14:59 GMT

Thumb Up

Come on, 3 hands?

This is obviously intended for the Japanese "pr0n-on the-mobe" market - the touch screen is operated via a user-supplied stylus.

remember this 

Posted Thursday 9th July 2009 18:43 GMT

Coffee/keyboard

from siemens?

http://w1.siemens.com/innovation/en/news_events/innovationnews/innovationnews_articles/information_communications/aneattwistblackberrycellphonewithconcealedkeyboard.htm